Does Homeowner’s Insurance Cover Tenant Vandalism?

What happens when your tenant destroys your home? Will your insurance policy cover the damages?

BMR Insurance recently encountered a situation up in Laguna Beach, where a tenant of a property stripped down the home to the bare drywall and inflicted $1.5 million worth of damage.  The tenant took fireplaces, railings, lights, windows, doors and every other fixture imaginable!  What are homeowners and landlords to do in such a situation?  We see many predicaments such as this (fortunately most are not as severe as the one we depicted), and our clients always wonder: Does homeowner’s insurance cover acts of vandalism and theft?

The answer is that standard homeowners insurance policies will generally not cover any damages inflicted by tenants; Homeowners insurance policies only cover residences lived by the actual homeowner, or to put it simply, covers only the property in which a homeowner lives.  Rental properties require a different policy under a rental homeowner’s policy known as a “dwelling fire policy”.  Under the dwelling fire policy, normal wear and tear damage is not covered, but preempted vandalism is.  However, in order to claim vandalism, homeowners must file a police report and press charges against the offender.

Again, all insurance policies are different, so BMR Insurance recommends all homeowners and landlords to check with their insurance companies to review their policies and get a better understanding of what is and isn’t covered under their premium.

Tenant vandalism cases are tricky because homeowners will need to present proof to back their claim in order to get compensation from their insurance company.  Of course this is not always possible and insurance companies might not honor the claim without proof.  Alternatively, landlords could take this issue to court and sue tenants in a small claims court for damages, but even so monetary collection is still complicated and difficult to obtain.  To avoid this all together, BMR Insurance recommends all landlords or homeowners who are renting their properties to enforce strict security deposit regulations, which will offer ample protection for the landlord and cover any damages caused by the tenant.

Again, remember to check with your insurance companies to see what liabilities your policy covers and doesn’t cover.  For a free insurance consultation, please contact BMR Insurance today at (714) 838-1911 or visit our website at bmrins.com.

Join the Conversation

7 Comments

  1. I have a tenant renting a room in my home in San Diego, Ca. area. I didn’t charge a deposit because he was rehabbing the room so I also agreed to lower the rent by $50. He has a convertable car so I said he could park in the garage and use it to work on it. Told him not to get in the rafters. He proceeded to remove, destroy personal property. Cut up my work bench, removed drawers, even threw some of my stuff out or hauled it o trash. Then he proceeded to park two cars not the one originally mentioned. And brought in tons of his personal garage items. The garage was never included in rent. Many personal items missing and I cannot get to anything in my garage. What arw my rights as a homeowner living in my own dwelling? He even removed a tree I planted from seed over 19 years ago and fed it to his chickens, which he built a huge hen house in a location other then the one I clearly specified

    1. Hi Catherine,
      Sorry to hear of your tenant problems! We can’t answer this in a comment, but please give us a call and we’ll be happy to walk you though it. (714) 838-1911

    2. Catherine Cook? Previously from Norman OK??????????????????? I was in insurance claims before I retired…………………

  2. I was wondering if my house Insurance policy would cover vandalized car and truck my car the wind shield was smashed and my t ruck the lugnuts were losser up .and I think if your home is vandalized your home owners should cover it .you should make a claim

    1. Sorry to hear of your vandalism! We can’t answer this in a comment, but please give us a call and we’ll be happy to walk you though it. (714) 838-1911

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *